Easily could Via Carota's website be ilovecarota dot com, like its sister restaurant www.ilovebuvette.com. Because I do (it's hard not to), both of them. Carota is virtually Buvette italianofied by chefs Jodi Williams and Rita Sodi, in a slightly airier space than its brethren just steps away. They share a no-reservations policy, but arriving early enough even on a near-perfectly weathered Monday night (there is limited outdoor seating, all of which was full) there was no wait for a table in the humbly decorated dining room, windows flung out to a busy West Village side street, glasses clinking and a soundtrack I would actually buy the whole of straight out.
That breezy availability of table might change drastically as either the hour of day or day of week progressed... busier nights have seen easy hour and a half waits. But we were whisked in and seated pleasantly, water glasses filled immediately, the default house-filtered tap gratis (as it should be). Menus are furled up in small cubbies in the back of the rustic wooden chairs, listing simple small plates ideal for sharing, but feasibly molded into an app/entree format too, if desired.
they are immaculately prepared. Gem-like chianti beets (weighing in the middle at $15) , shiny as rubies with their gentle slick of oil, are mingled with translucent coils of pickly white onion and creamy, crumbly ricotta salata. The vegetables themselves aren't too trimmed and perfect, giving them a farmy sincerity that becomes perfect in its own right. Funghi are a wild mix with a heady, earthy perfume, perfectly roasted so their rich flavor is augmented by a bit of chew. They disguise a luxurious blob of smoky scamorza, but consume quickly, as it's
There are four pastas on hand, all priced in the high teens, but substantial enough to more than justify the price. A wild boar ragu bedecked floppy pappardelle, and there was a special tagliatelle described by our waitress, along with a handful of other daily off-the-menu specials in all categories. (She had quite a bit to remember, as well as struggle with a pretty feeble grasp of the
not only veggie scarce, but the only disappointment of the night, the lamb far too fatty with a paucity of meat. I might've been happier with a simple grilled chicken.. or even just another selection of Verdure. Which would've made the meal here even more reasonable, but price-wise Via Carota is still a very moderate establishment. If your bill ends up too steep, you probably over-ordered.... or indulged in their exquisitely curated wine menu, that while offering bottles and glassees at both ends of the spectrum, always pads the bill.
I guess dessert wasn't quite as magnificent a finish as I might have wished for, either. But a simple dish of wine-sweetened raspberries topped with a thick dollops of zabaglione was still pleasant. The raspberries had that supermarket-perfect appearance, though, making me wish for the months to warm up past April and bring on farmer's market bounty of plush berries and drippy sink peaches. While the rest of Via Carota's menu can accomodate all the fluctuations and variances of seasonality, desserts always shine brighter in summer's abundance. So while the restaurant as a whole is already a definite crowd-pleaser, I anticipate summer is when she will really hit her sweet stride.
Dal lunedì al venerdì 11:00—24:00
Fine settimana 11:00—24:00